Honestly
Where this is weakest
A 20 percent rise is the question this engine handles best, and it still has holes worth knowing before you put the output in front of anyone.
On the invented Harborline record the arithmetic is clean: at 31 percent gross margin, a 20 percent rise takes gross profit per unit from 31 cents to 51 cents in the dollar, so volume could fall 39 percent before the company is back where it started. That number is a ceiling on the bad case, not a forecast, and it assumes the rise reaches everybody, which it does not.
- One elasticity carries the whole book, adjusted only by three segment multipliers. Real price response differs by product line and the model has no product lines
- The price index applies to everything. Volume tiers, mix and the discount your field is already giving are not in it
- The competitor set is fixed. Nobody new enters because your price went up
- Customers can leave, or renew 3 percent cheaper. They cannot cut scope, move volume to a second source, or stretch payment terms
- There is no announcement. The model has no notion of how the letter was written, who called whom first, or whether you gave notice
What this cannot tell you